In keeping with the theme, I picked up these paper straws and cut out moustaches from black cardboard stock. I happen to have friends who don't mind poking fun at themselves. To hold plasticware and the straws, I dressed up these mason jars with strips of leftover cardboard stock that I used for the pennants.
In a moment of synchronicity, while wandering around Target looking for nothing in particular, The Dutch and I saw these paper plates and napkins that exactly match our party decor. They were $1 each pack of 8 - at 70% off! Time to hoard!